Document Type

Dissertation

Date of Degree

10-28-2026

Primary Advisor

Paige McDonald

Abstract

Background: In the United States, Black men experience significant health disparities, including higher rates of preventable chronic illnesses and lower life expectancy compared to other demographic groups. These disparities are strongly linked to lower healthcare utilization, which may be influenced by a lack of trust in healthcare providers. While the literature highlights the need to build trust between Black men and healthcare providers, there is a lack of understanding of the determinants of trust from the perspective of Black men. This explanatory sequential mixed-methods study examined the factors that influence Black men’s trust in healthcare providers in the Washington, D.C., metropolitan region. The specific outcome of this study was to understand how Black men determine trust in healthcare providers to inform the development of future trust-building strategies and interventions.

Methods: This study used an explanatory sequential mixed-methods study design that consisted of a quantitative, qualitative, and integrative phase. During the quantitative phase, 170 self-identified Black men aged 18-89 years from the Washington, D.C., metropolitan area completed a demographic survey and the validated 29-item Trust in Doctors in General (T-DiG) scale. Descriptive statistics, one-way analysis of variance, chi-square analysis, and multiple linear regression were conducted to analyze the relationship between healthcare provider trust and age, income, educational level, having a healthcare provider, and having health insurance. The qualitative phase consisted of semi-structured interviews with 17 survey participants to gain a better understanding of how Black men experience trust in healthcare providers. Interview data were analyzed using the Data Analysis Spiral Method and inductive thematic coding. The quantitative and qualitative findings were then integrated using a joint display matrix.

Results: The mean healthcare provider trust score was 97.1 (SD= 17.6), indicating an overall medium-high level of trust among the participants. Education level was identified as a correlate of trust, with higher education corresponding to higher trust scores. Age and income level were not independently significant predictors of trust but interacted with education level in the regression model. Having a healthcare provider was significantly associated with trust levels, and having health insurance was not a significant predictor. Despite the overall medium-high trust scores, participants expressed a high degree of polarity in levels of trust regarding healthcare provider financial motives, racial fairness, transparency, and medical experimentation. A total of five qualitative themes emerged from the interviews: Feeling Seen and Heard by Healthcare Providers; Trust in Provider Knowledge, Honesty, and Integrity; Navigating Race, Culture, and Fair Treatment in Healthcare; Financial Motives and Experimentation as Barriers to Trust; and Trust Shaped by Personal Beliefs and Identities. The integrated findings showed that access to healthcare providers and having health insurance did not automatically promote trust. Instead, trust was found to be shaped by interpersonal engagement, provider competence, honesty, continuity of care, cultural sensitivity, perceptions of fairness, and participants’ unique personal experiences.

Conclusion: Black men’s trust in healthcare providers is a complex and multifaceted phenomenon that is influenced by individual, interpersonal, cultural, and systemic factors. Although participants reported overall medium-high levels of trust, concerns related to healthcare provider's motives, racial fairness, communication and transparency remained. These findings highlight the need for focused trust-building interventions that encourage respectful communication, patient education, provider transparency, cultural humility, continuity of care, and shared decision making. The findings from this study may be used to inform future healthcare provider training, health professions curricula, and community-based interventions focused on strengthening patient-provider relationships and the promotion of healthcare-seeking behavior in the Black male community.

Comments

©2026 by Aaron P. Henry. All rights reserved. 

Open Access

1

Available for download on Monday, May 10, 2027

Find in your library

Share

COinS