Hypertension: Are Current Guidelines Inclusive of Sex and Gender?
Journal of women's health (2002)
disparity; gender; guideline; hypertension; sex; transgender; women's health
Hypertension (HTN) accounts for one in five deaths of American women. Major societies worldwide aim to make evidence-based recommendations for HTN management. Sex- or gender-based differences exist in epidemiology and management of HTN; in this study, we aimed to assess sex- and gender-based language in major society guidelines. We reviewed HTN guidelines from four societies: the American College of Cardiology (ACC), the American College of Emergency Physicians (ACEP), the European Society of Cardiology (ESC), and the Eighth Joint National Committee (JNC8). We quantified the sex- and gender-based medicine (SGBM) content by word count in each guideline as well as identified the gender of guideline authors. Two of the four HTN guidelines (ACC, ESC) included SGBM content. Of these two guidelines, there were variations in the quantity and depth of content coverage. Pregnancy had the highest word count found in both guidelines (422 words in ACC and 1,523 words in ESC), which represented 2.45% and 3.04% of the total words in each guideline, respectively. There was minimal coverage, if any, of any other life periods. The number of women authors did not impact the SGBM content within a given guideline. Current HTN management guidelines do not provide optimal guidance on sex- and gender-based differences. Inclusion of sex, gender identity, hormone therapy, pregnancy and lactation status, menopause, and advanced age in future research will be critical to bridge the current evidence gap. Guideline writing committees should include diverse perspectives, including cisgender and transgender persons from diverse racial and ethnic backgrounds.
Griffin, Brooke L.; Bolch, Charlotte A.; Bourjeily, Ghada; Madsen, Tracy E.; Hasnain, Memoona; McGregor, Alyson J.; Merhi, Basma O.; Pratt-Chapman, Mandi L.; Romano, Mary; Trott, Justina; and Tong, Iris, "Hypertension: Are Current Guidelines Inclusive of Sex and Gender?" (2022). GW Authored Works. Paper 1852.